Men's McGuffey Plain Toe Shoes

$119.90
Color:Brown
Size: Please select

Product details

Web ID: 3096298

Johnston & Murphy's best-selling construction top-rated for comfort and style.

  • Product Features

    • Shoe width - medium and wide
    • Updated textures and styles add interest
    • Supple oiled full-grain leather or soft matte nubuck and breathable knit
    • Lightweight Strobel construction
    • Leather performance fabric-covered cushioned insole
    • Full Grain Leather, Lining - Skeletal Leather
    • Spot Clean
    • Imported

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item may not be shipped to U.S. Virgin Islands, Armed Forces Europe, Palau, Guam, Puerto Rico, Marshall Islands, Northern Mariana, Federated States of Micronesia, Armed Forces Americas, Armed Forces Pacific, Hawaii, American Samoa, Alaska
    • Returns are accepted at any Macy's store within 30 days from purchase date. Last Act items are final sale and sold “as is.” No returns, exchanges, or price adjustments allowed.
    • California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.
    • Please call customer service for returns.

Ratings & Reviews

Here's what customers think
  • Many customers found the shoes comfortable, stylish, and versatile for various occasions
  • Positive feedback highlighted the good fit, quality, and overall appearance
  • Some users reported issues with discoloration, durability, and sizing problems
  • A few reviewers noted a decline in quality compared to previous purchases
  • The shoes seem to be a generally good casual option, but there are concerns about consistency in quality and reliability
AI-generated summary from 497 customers reviews.
4.4/5

502 star ratings, 497 reviews

Write a Review
350
67
36
25
24

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Neutral.

16 customer images

497 reviewssorted by Newest

Tar
21 days ago

Looks good but bad quality

Sole is worn out after 6 months and the bottom of the shoe where the leather meets the rubber that is made to look like it’s stitched together is coming apart in multiple places 👎

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Response from Johnston & Murphy

Johnston & Murphy Customer Service17 days ago

We're so sorry to hear that there's an issue with the stitching your McGuffey Plain Toe! This is not representative of our quality standards. Please reach out to us- we want you to love your McGuffeys and would be more than happy to discuss what we can do to resolve this issue. Johnston & Murphy Customer Service (800) 424-2854 johnstonmurphy@johnstonmurphy.com https://www.johnstonmurphy.com/help.html

Shoes
2 months ago

Bottom Wore Out

They are nice shoes but the bottoms wore out in less than 6 months and that’s only from wearing them into the office 3 days a week maximum. For the price, very disappointed in the quality and expected them to last longer

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
2 months ago

Very comfortable

Great shoe and nice casual style. Exactly what I was looking for.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Troy
4 months ago

Great style

Great looking, very comfortable. The size and description were accurate. I wore them the first time and received compliments.

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
4 months ago

Perfectly comfortable shoes. Highly recommend.

Excellent shoes. I own 6 different pairs. All very comfortable and easy to clean Highly recommend.

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Chuck
4 months ago

Nice Kicks

Nice shoes. Properly burnished toe area, good color. Ample support. Very comfortable. I've bought many pairs of JohnstonMurphy shoes and am, as always, pleased with the fit and other important aspects of the shoe.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Jeremy
5 months ago

Great shoe for the business casual

Great shoe for the business casual work environment. These are my daily go-to shoe for when I’m working in the office.

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
5 months ago

Excellent leather

My husband is very discerning (picky). He loves these shoes! We just ordered another pair because his old ones were about a year old. I decided to use a little saddle soap on his old pair. The leather is so good, they look like new. Now he has two pair and is very happy!

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy